Ekklisia

English · Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά →

The priesthood of all believers

21 November 2026 · 12 min read

In a series from the books of Stylianos Charalampakis — the case for the priesthood of all believers, from the book The Royal Priesthood.

Salvation asked how we are saved. The priesthood asks who stands between God and us — and whether anyone needs to. It is the question underneath the vestments, the ordination and the confession: does the Christian faith need a special class of priests, or did Christ end that need for good? For someone considering Orthodoxy, the answer shapes everything about church life — who can baptise, who can preside at the Eucharist, who can pronounce forgiveness, and how direct a believer's access to God is.

The guide for this piece is an unusual one: a book of 33 letters written to the Ecumenical Patriarch by a man who had been an Orthodox priest himself. Stylianos I. Charalampakis served twelve years as a cleric, studied the question of the priesthood in detail, and reached the conclusion that there is no “special priesthood” in the Christian dispensation — so he defrocked himself, freely and of his own accord, because his conscience would not let him practise as a profession what he had come to condemn. The first thirteen letters went to a priest and a bishop; the rest went to Patriarch Athenagoras I, prompted by the procession of the Axion Esti icon of Mount Athos to Athens and Piraeus on 17 April 1963. The book is Το Βασίλειον Ιεράτευμα — The Royal Priesthood. Its tone is often polemical, and this piece does not reproduce that rhetoric: it takes the arguments and the evidence, in the measured voice this series aims for, and states the Orthodox position first, fairly, before answering it.

1. What Orthodoxy teaches: a special priesthood

The Orthodox Church teaches that Christ gave the Church a sacramental priesthood, passed on by ordination in unbroken succession from the apostles. Its ministry has three degrees — bishop, priest (presbyter) and deacon — and the priest, ordained by the bishop, celebrates the mysteries: above all the Eucharist, and baptism, chrismation, confession and the other sacraments. In confession the priest pronounces absolution; at the altar he offers the Eucharist on behalf of the people. Charalampakis himself states the dogmatic position he is arguing against without caricature: Orthodoxy “dogmatically accepts the need for an earthly priesthood, which will exercise the triple office of the Lord, the prophetic, the high-priestly and the royal — that is, the preaching of the divine Word, the celebration of the mysteries, and the governing of the faithful.”

That is the claim to be examined, and it is worth feeling its weight before answering it. The priesthood is not presented as a human invention bolted onto the Church, but as the way Christ continues to act among his people — the hands through which he gives his sacraments, the voice through which he pronounces forgiveness. A church that lost the priesthood, on this view, would lose the sacraments themselves. The evangelical answer has to be more than a dislike of ceremony: it has to show, from Scripture, that what the priest is said to do is something Christ has already done, once for all, and given to his whole people.

2. The torn veil

Charalampakis begins where the New Testament begins the argument — with the torn veil. “And behold, the curtain of the temple was torn in two, from top to bottom” (Matthew 27:51). The book's epigraph draws the conclusion in one line: the mediator-priests are abolished, “for henceforth all are welcome into the presence of God.” In the old covenant, priests were necessary because they offered sacrifices and mediated before God for the sins of the people. In the Christian dispensation, Charalampakis argues, that work has stopped — because the sacrifice has been made. “But when Christ had offered for all time a single sacrifice for sins… For by a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:12–14). Where there are no more sacrifices, there is no more sacrifice-offering priesthood.

The positive side of the same argument is the royal priesthood of all believers. “You are a royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9) — the verse that gives the book its title. All Christians, Charalampakis writes in his introduction, form a “kingdom of priests,” a royal priesthood, as the Bible calls them and as the ancient church writers called them. The book's title is not his invention but the New Testament's own language, applied to the whole people of God rather than to a class within it. And the access that follows is direct: Christ “is at the right hand of God, who indeed is interceding for us” (Romans 8:34), and he “is able to save to the uttermost those who draw near to God through him, since he always lives to make intercession for them” (Hebrews 7:25). “For it was indeed fitting that we should have such a high priest, holy, innocent, unstained, separated from sinners, and exalted above the heavens… one who is seated at the right hand of the throne of the Majesty in heaven, a minister in the holy places” (Hebrews 7:26; 8:1–2). One Priest and High Priest, in the Christian dispensation, and he is the Son of God — and through him, all have the right and the authority to approach God's presence.

The evangelical reader will recognise this as common ground, not a sectarian claim. The veil torn, the one sacrifice, the one High Priest who lives to intercede — these are the passages on which the Reformation's priesthood of all believers was built, and they are the reason evangelical churches have pastors rather than priests. The disagreement with Orthodoxy is not about whether the Church needs ministers, teachers and overseers. It is about whether those ministers constitute a separate priestly order with an exclusive sacramental power, or whether they are what the New Testament calls them: presbyters and bishops, elders and overseers, servants of a people who are all priests.

3. Presbyters and bishops — and no priests

The longest historical argument in the book is also the simplest: in the apostolic age, presbyter and bishop were one and the same person. The names were equivalent and interchangeable. Paul calls for the presbyters of the church at Ephesus, and then tells those same men that the Holy Spirit has made them bishops, to shepherd the church of God (Acts 20:17, 28). He greets the church at Philippi “with the overseers and deacons” (Philippians 1:1), writes of appointing presbyters in every town and then describes the bishop in the same breath (Titus 1:5–7), and Peter addresses his fellow-presbyters as a fellow-presbyter (1 Peter 5:1). The qualifications for the office are listed in the same passages (1 Timothy 3:1–12; 5:17). Reading them, Charalampakis concludes, we find that the name “bishop” was given to the presbyter according to his field of action — two names for one office — and that in no point do the presbyters hold the place of the priest.

The point is not antiquarian. If the New Testament knows two orders — presbyter-bishops and deacons — and no third order of sacrificing priests, then the three degrees of the later priesthood are a development, not an apostolic institution. Charalampakis presses this against the Orthodox dogmatician Panagiotis Trembelas, who concedes that at first, while the apostles and their fellow-workers were still alive, the clergy had two orders — presbyters called bishops, and deacons — and then appeals to Ignatius and Polycarp, disciples of John, as mentioning the three degrees. Charalampakis disputes the appeal: the three degrees, he argues, are not found in the apostolic writings, and a later witness cannot put back into the apostolic age what the apostles themselves never established. Readers will judge that historical argument for themselves; what matters for the dialogue is that the Orthodox side of it is not ignored. The Orthodox answer is that the threefold ministry did develop early, under the apostles' own successors, and that development is itself part of the Church's tradition — which is why the question ultimately has to be settled by asking what Scripture and Tradition are, and who decides: the subject of the companion piece, What Orthodoxy teaches about Scripture and Tradition.

4. One High Priest, after the order of Melchizedek

The book devotes a whole letter to the priesthood of Christ “after the order of Melchizedek” (Hebrews 7), and the argument is the heart of the case. The old priesthood belonged to a tribe, passed from father to son, and ended with death; the new High Priest holds his priesthood permanently, because he lives for ever. His is not a priesthood that can be handed on to successors, because it does not need to be: the sacrifice has been offered once, and the intercession never stops. That is why, Charalampakis argues, the New Testament never calls any Christian minister a priest in the sacrificial sense — the word is reserved for Christ, and for the whole people. A further letter takes up apostolic succession directly: the priests, he argues, are not successors of the apostles, and the patriarchal lists produced to prove the succession do not bear the weight put on them. The apostles' successors, on this reading, are those who teach what the apostles taught — succession of doctrine, not of office.

Here the fair statement of the Orthodox position matters most, because this is where the two sides talk past each other. When Orthodoxy speaks of the priest as successor of the apostles, it does not mean the priest replaces Christ, or that Christ's priesthood is divided among many. It means Christ acts through the priest in the sacraments — the priest is the instrument, not the source. The evangelical objection is not that God cannot act through human instruments; it is that the New Testament gives no sign that he appointed a distinct priestly order to be that instrument, and every sign that the one High Priest's work is complete. If Hebrews is right that one offering has perfected for ever those who are being sanctified, then a priesthood whose purpose is to offer sacrifice has nothing left to offer — and a ministry whose purpose is to preach, teach and shepherd needs no priestly character added to it.

5. The three offices belong to all

The book's most striking claim comes in its fifteenth letter: the Christian has all three offices of Christ. The triple office — prophetic, priestly and royal — is not the property of the clergy. God, Charalampakis writes, “provides to all faithful, regenerate believers these glorious privileges of the triple office of the Lord,” because through them he fixes the position of the worshippers “without any distinction between clergy and laity,” and gives the means for the life of Jesus Christ on earth to be continued by all the members of the Church. The life of every member becomes “one continuous worship and doxology and hymn to God.” He quotes Chrysostom on the point: God gave the Holy Spirit, “through whom… he made us at once prophets (teachers) and priests and kings.” And he quotes Trembelas himself, from The Laity in the Church: “When such names and such descriptions are given by God himself to the people… the people has rights not from human law but from divine law; not from natural but from supernatural law.”

The practical consequence follows in the same letter, and it is the claim on which the whole argument stands or falls. The mysteries, he argues, were unknown to the first Christian centuries except for baptism and the Lord's Supper — and those, “according to Holy Scripture and the first apologists, all regenerate Christians have the right to celebrate.” For reasons of good order they were celebrated by the presider, whom nobody called a priest; and even though all have the right, they should always be celebrated by the presider alone. But where the presider is absent, or the Church is in its infancy and has none, “any Christian ‘full of the Holy Spirit’ may celebrate” them. That is Charalampakis's position, stated as his: the right belongs to the whole royal priesthood, the exercise of it is ordered by the Church. Orthodox readers will disagree with the first half of that sentence — for them the celebration of the mysteries belongs to the ordained priest alone, by the Church's own order, not merely for convenience. The disagreement is real, and it is the disagreement this series exists to hold in the open: whether the Church's good order is a discipline that serves the priesthood of all believers, or a sacramental boundary that defines who may approach God on behalf of others.

Why it matters — three questions

None of this is about vestments or titles. It is about access. If a special priesthood stands between the believer and God, then the believer's approach to God runs through another man's hands — and the question of who that man is, and whether he is validly ordained, becomes the question on which everything else hangs. If the royal priesthood is the whole people, then the approach is direct, through the one High Priest, and the minister's task is to preach the Word, administer the sacraments in good order, and shepherd the flock — the work of a presbyter, not the sacrifice of a priest. Three questions are worth carrying into any decision about which of these to join.

Who mediates for you? If you need a priest to pronounce forgiveness, to celebrate the Eucharist, to stand between you and God, ask what Scripture says he is doing that Christ has not already done — once, completely, and for ever.

What is a pastor for? The New Testament gives the Church teachers, evangelists and shepherds, and it gives them real authority — to preach, to correct, to govern, to guard the flock. It never gives them a sacrifice to offer. Ask whether the ministry you are joining is defined by the Word and the oversight of the flock, or by a priestly power the apostles never claimed.

What would you be joining — an order, or a people? The royal priesthood is not a metaphor for the laity's dignity; in Charalampakis's argument it is the Church's actual constitution. A church of priests has no clerical class to join and no lay class to remain in. Ask which picture fits the Church you read about in the Acts of the Apostles — and which one you want your children to grow up in.

That is the conversation this series exists for. The question underneath this one — how the Church knows what the apostles taught — is taken up in the companion series, in What Orthodoxy teaches about Scripture and Tradition. The letters have more to say on binding and loosing: what it meant, to whom it was given, and whether the apostles ever used it as priestly power.

Sources: Stylianos I. Charalampakis, Το Βασίλειον Ιεράτευμα (The Royal Priesthood), 33 letters to the Ecumenical Patriarch — the first thirteen to a priest and a bishop, the rest to Patriarch Athenagoras I, prompted by the procession of the Axion Esti icon to Athens and Piraeus on 17 April 1963. The argument here is drawn chiefly from the Introduction, Letter 2 (Hebrews 10:12–14; Romans 8:34; Hebrews 7:25–26; 8:1–2), with the torn veil in the book’s epigraph, Letter 15 (the three offices of Christ; Chrysostom and Trembelas as Charalampakis quotes them), Letter 24 (presbyter and bishop one person; Acts 20:17, 28; Philippians 1:1; 1 Timothy 3:1–12; Titus 1:5–7; 1 Peter 5:1) and Letters 29–30 (the priesthood after the order of Melchizedek; apostolic succession). Fair use throughout: short quotations with attribution, mostly summary and paraphrase; the book's polemical rhetoric is not reproduced. Honest limits: this piece is built from the book's text, not from a fresh reading of the Fathers or the dogmatic sources Charalampakis cites — Chrysostom, Trembelas and the early writers appear as he quotes them, and his historical claims (for example about the development of the three degrees) are his, to be weighed against the Orthodox account; the Orthodox position is stated from the book's own summary of it and from the Church's standard teaching; nothing is drawn from Charalampakis's second book, Τὰ Ἀνάποδα τῆς Θρησκείας, whose text has now been recovered by OCR (all 377 pages) but was not used for this piece. Scripture references are those cited in the letters; quotations follow the English Standard Version.

Related reading: The man who wrote to the Patriarch — the story of the man and his letters; What Orthodoxy teaches about Scripture and Tradition — in the “What Orthodoxy teaches” series, on the question underneath this one; What Orthodoxy teaches about salvation — on salvation; What Orthodoxy teaches about the toll-houses — on the toll-houses; Orthodox Soteriology — four talks by Rev. Giotis Kantartzis; Ecclesiology — nine talks by Sotiris Boukis on what the Church is; In dialogue with Orthodoxy — the dialogue these pieces belong to.

Researched and drafted with the help of Muse, an AI assistant. Every claim is checked against its sources, and every article is approved by Aris Angelakopoulos before publication.