What Orthodoxy teaches about salvation
Salvation is the right place to start this series, because it is where the two traditions most visibly part ways — and where the difference is easiest to misunderstand. An evangelical who walks into an Orthodox church will hear familiar words: grace, faith, the Cross, the sacraments, eternal life. The words are the same. What they mean, and how they fit together, is not always the same. This piece states the Orthodox teaching first, fairly and from its own sources, and then asks what Scripture says — including where the two part ways.
The main guide here is the teaching series already on this site: four talks by Rev. Giotis Kantartzis, pastor of the 1st Evangelical Church of Athens, on Orthodox soteriology. Kantartzis does what this series aims to do throughout — he engages the real Orthodox theologians, above all Kallistos Ware, John Meyendorff, Vladimir Lossky and Nikos Matsoukas, takes their position seriously, and then answers it. Where a claim below comes from one of them, it is named; where it is Kantartzis's own reading of them, that is said too.
1. The problem: what went wrong in the Fall
Kantartzis's opening point is that the two traditions disagree about the problem before they disagree about the cure. If we disagree about what happened in the Fall, we will disagree about what salvation is and how it is experienced.
The West — Protestant and Roman Catholic alike, as heirs of Augustine — speaks of original sin: what happened in Eden concerns us directly. We are born guilty, under the dominion of sin, and the punishment of sin is eternal death. That is the position stated in the Confession of Faith of the Greek Evangelical Church, which Kantartzis quotes: man was created innocent, chose evil, his relationship with God was broken, and no one can be saved except by the grace of God.
The East speaks instead of ancestral sin (προπατορικό αμάρτημα). The sin of the forefathers is separated from us: we inherit only its consequences — corruption, death, mortality. Sin, in Matsoukas's account, is not first a moral and legal matter — guilt, a debt to be paid — but rebellion, a hubristic self-will seeking equality with God: a rupture of relationships, the loss of the deifying energy, the darkening of the mind. The Fall is not so much a fall from a position as a failure to fulfil man's calling. He has the image of God; likeness — theosis — is a goal still to be reached. Man stumbled and lost a future good. Death, on this view, is not a punishment God imposes but an invasion, the natural consequence of distancing oneself from God, who is life. Irenaeus's image, which Kantartzis cites, is of an immature child and a father who nurses his sick child rather than punishing him.
The evangelical objection is not to the parts of this that are true. That sin ruptures relationships, darkens the mind and ends in death is common ground. The objection is to what the picture leaves out. Romans 5 speaks not only of consequences but of transgression, judgment and condemnation (Romans 5:15, 16, 18) — language that will not fit a Fall in which nothing was imputed to us. And Kantartzis presses a sharp question: if death were simply the automatic consequence of distancing oneself from God, the devil — distanced from God completely — would not still be alive. Something more than distance is going on, and Scripture names it as guilt before a holy God.
2. The Cross: triumph — and sacrifice
Because the problem is understood differently, the Cross is understood differently. For Orthodoxy, the Cross is first of all triumph and victory over death. The resurrection troparion says it in one line: “Christ is risen from the dead, trampling down death by death, and upon those in the tombs bestowing life.” Ware insists that crucifixion and resurrection are not separated but are one single act: Golgotha is always seen in the light of the empty tomb, and Christ is the victorious King who triumphs precisely through his crucifixion.
Meyendorff, in Byzantine Theology, makes the historical point behind it: Byzantine theology never developed Paul's doctrine of justification in Romans and Galatians in any significant way. The Greek Fathers did not treat redemption through substitution as central; they understood the Cross within the wider frame of victory over death and sanctification. Gregory of Nazianzus put it as Kantartzis quotes him: “We needed a God who took flesh and died, so that we might live.”
Here the evangelical response is: yes — and not only that. The victory over death is real, and any account of the Cross that loses it is poorer for it. But if the problem were only mortality, any death would do. Why then this specific death, with its penal and legal dimension? Romans 3:25–26 says God appointed Christ as the propitiation through faith, showing that he is both just and the justifier of the one who believes. First Peter 3:18 says “the righteous for the unrighteous.” Colossians 2:13–15 holds both together in a single passage: God forgave our trespasses, cancelled the record of debt by nailing it to the Cross, and disarmed the rulers and authorities in his triumph. Hebrews 2:14–18 does the same: through death Christ destroyed the one who holds the power of death, the devil, and freed those whom fear of death held in slavery. The Cross is triumph (Christus Victor) and sacrifice — and it is the triune God who acts, not, as John Stott stressed, a passive Father who must be appeased. Love comes first — “God so loved the world” (John 3:16) — but love contains holiness, and holiness is expressed in wrath (John 3:36). The cup of Gethsemane is the Old Testament cup of God's judgment, which Christ drinks on the Cross.
3. The goal: theosis
For Orthodox theology the central term for the experience of salvation is theosis — deification, becoming like God — just as justification is central for Protestant theology. But as Norman Russell shows, not everyone means the same thing by the word, so it needs unpacking. Kantartzis distinguishes two senses. Theosis as moral perfection — becoming increasingly like God, with imitation as the key concept — is almost synonymous with what evangelicals call sanctification, a lifelong journey of becoming like God. That is common ground, with one caveat: in Orthodox theology theosis, or sanctification, is synonymous with salvation itself, not a stage after it.
Theosis as ontological change goes further: “to exist in the manner of the uncreated,” in Christos Yannaras's phrase — a real participation in God. Gregory Palamas's distinction between God's essence and his energies, from the fourteenth century, is what makes that participation possible without pantheism: man never participates in God's essence, but in his uncreated energies, which are the real manifestation of God. In the hesychast controversies on Mount Athos, monks testified to seeing a light in prayer — if it is uncreated light, there is real participation, a theotic experience.
The evangelical answer is yes and no. Ontological change belongs to the biblical picture of salvation — Romans 8:30, “those he justified, he also glorified,” and Philippians 3:20–21, where Christ will transform our lowly body to be conformed to his glorious body — but the disagreement is about how and when it happens. The hardest point is the hesychastic vision of the uncreated light: is that what Scripture presents as the believer's experience? In the Transfiguration the Word of God is central — Moses, Elijah, the voice from heaven — not something to bypass but the very path. And Paul did not seek his Damascus-road experience; it came to him. Theosis also belongs to a wider theological mosaic and cannot be cut out and used on its own — above all, the question of how an ordinary person reaches it. Kantartzis tells of a bishop asking Russell, in Athens, how a married man with three children, a job and debts could live the ascetic path to theosis; the answer was an embarrassed smile. Ware's own simpler answer to “how can I become God?” was: “Go to church, receive the sacraments, pray to God, read the Gospels, follow the commandments” — “do what you can, and God will do the rest.”
4. How, then, are we saved?
The final talk turns to the practical question, guided by Ware's booklet How Are We Saved? Asked “are you saved?”, Ware answered: “I hope, by God's grace, to be saved; I am in the process of salvation.” In Orthodox theology salvation is a process, completed only at the end of the journey. Kantartzis names three points of difference from the Protestant understanding: the logic of synergy against the paradox of grace; the high realism of sacramental life; and the lack of assurance.
Synergy is the idea that man cooperates with God's grace in his salvation. Nicholas Cabasilas, in his Marian homilies, presents the Virgin realising in herself and offering to God the things that attracted the Creator — a spotless life, purity — so that it was only just she become the Lord's mother. Lossky denies that this is merit, insisting salvation remains a gift; Kantartzis's view is that the lines get blurred. Luther, commenting on the Magnificat (Luke 1), saw Mary as a vessel of election precisely because of her unworthiness: God “does not discover, but creates what is pleasing to him in us.”
Sacramental realism: in Cabasilas's On the Life in Christ, union with Christ is realised through the mysteries — baptism gives existence in Christ, chrismation perfects the newborn by imparting the energy for this life, the Eucharist sustains it. The mysteries nourish faith and are means of grace; what Kantartzis finds missing is the existential dimension of faith — the mysteries do not by themselves insert us into God's life. And the exclusive ecclesiology that goes with them implies there is no salvation outside the Orthodox Church.
Assurance: for evangelicals assurance is central — distinct from security, the question of whether salvation can be lost, on which evangelicals disagree among themselves. In Orthodoxy, salvation as a process means no one can say “I am saved.” Ware writes that few have been deified in this life, and — Kantartzis notes — his The Orthodox Church contains no reference to justification at all. Ware's own words are: “I remain between hope and fear until the last moment of death.” The order differs, Kantartzis observes: for Ware, Christ's work is perfect but I am imperfect, so I cannot have assurance; in Protestant theology, I am imperfect but God's work is perfect, so grounded in it I can have assurance. Philippians 2:12–13 holds the tension: “Work out your salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you” — I work because God is already working in me. And Luther's discovery reading Romans was that the righteousness of God is not the righteousness God demands but righteousness as a gift received by faith — “as if the gates of heaven had opened.” Without that language, the experience of assurance is lost. Justification and sanctification must be distinguished, not confused: “I press on to take hold of that for which Christ took hold of me” (Philippians 3:12) — like the prodigal son, who is a son from the moment his father embraces him, though he must relearn how to live as a son.
Kantartzis closes the series where it began — with the Cross, and with a prayer. The Jesus Prayer, “Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, the sinner,” expresses repentance and contrition. What is missing, he says, is the moment to say “thank you, for I have been shown mercy.” Paul says it in 1 Timothy 1:12–16: “I thank Christ Jesus our Lord… though I was once a blasphemer and a persecutor and a violent man, I was shown mercy… Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners — of whom I am the worst. But for that very reason I was shown mercy.” At some point the believer must be able to say: “Lord, have mercy — but glory to your name, for I have been shown mercy.”
Why it matters — three questions
None of this is abstract. For someone considering Orthodoxy, it is the question of what they would actually be signing up to — not the liturgy or the icons first, but the answer to “how am I saved, and how do I know?” Three questions are worth carrying into that decision.
Can you say “I have been shown mercy” — or only “I hope to be”? If salvation is a process that ends only at death, assurance is, by definition, out of reach in this life. If it rests on a finished work received by faith, assurance is not presumption; it is gratitude.
Is the Cross a victory you share in, or a sacrifice made for you? The honest answer is both — but a church that preaches only the victory will, sooner or later, leave its people unsure what was actually paid, and for whom.
Where does the theosis you are offered lead — to imitation, or to participation? Becoming like God in holiness is common ground. Becoming God by nature is not on offer anywhere in Scripture. Ask which one is being promised, and by what means — and whether an ordinary believer, married, with children, a job and debts, can actually walk the path that is described.
That is the conversation this series exists for. The next piece takes up Scripture and Tradition.
Sources: Rev. Giotis Kantartzis, “Orthodox Soteriology from an Evangelical Perspective,” four talks on the e-ekklisia YouTube channel (playlist PLElHxAQyzM12845UxRHBWeLs6mJgFrmi8), transcribed and published with timestamped main points on this site: Orthodox Soteriology. Talk 1, “The problem with the problem” (39:52); Talk 2, “Sacrifice or Triumph” (41:46); Talk 3, “Theosis” (30:17); Talk 4, “How, then, are we saved?” (40:08). Orthodox theologians are quoted here as Kantartzis presents them: Kallistos Ware (The Orthodox Church; How Are We Saved?), John Meyendorff (Byzantine Theology), Vladimir Lossky, Nikos Matsoukas (The Problem of Evil), Nicholas Cabasilas (On the Life in Christ), Gregory Palamas, Christos Yannaras and Norman Russell; the evangelical side draws on the Confession of Faith of the Greek Evangelical Church, Luther's On the Bondage of the Will and Heidelberg Disputation, and John Stott. Honest limits: this piece is built from the Kantartzis talks and their transcripts, not from a fresh reading of Ware, Meyendorff or the other Orthodox sources named — their words are given as Kantartzis cites them, and no Orthodox source beyond those he engages is claimed; two attributions in the talks are Kantartzis's own readings (that Ware's The Orthodox Church contains no reference to justification, and that Matsoukas's book on evil mentions the Cross only once or twice) and are stated as such; Scripture references are those cited in the talks.
Related reading: Orthodox Soteriology — the four talks this piece is drawn from, with video, timestamped main points and English subtitles; Ecclesiology — nine talks by Sotiris Boukis on what the Church is; In dialogue with Orthodoxy — the series this piece opens, with the topics to come: Scripture and Tradition, icons, the Theotokos, the sacraments, prayer to the saints.