Ekklisia

English · Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά →

What Orthodoxy teaches about Scripture and Tradition

21 November 2026 · 17 min read

In the “What Orthodoxy teaches” series — for anyone thinking of becoming Orthodox, and for evangelicals who want to understand their Orthodox neighbours.

Every disagreement in this series comes back to a single question: by what authority? The pieces on salvation and the toll-houses were argued from the Fathers, the councils, the hymns and the icons — but behind every appeal to a Father or a council stands a prior question. What counts as an authority at all? Who decides? And what happens when the authorities disagree? This piece takes up the question on which all the others turn: what the Orthodox Church teaches about Scripture and Tradition.

The Orthodox answer is not what most Western Christians expect. It is not that Scripture and Tradition are two separate sources, one written and one unwritten, standing side by side. It is that there is one source, and that Scripture lives inside it. This piece states that answer first, fairly and from its own sources, and then asks what Scripture says.

1. One source, not two

The fullest statement of the Orthodox position in English is the chapter “Holy Tradition: The Source of the Orthodox Faith” in Kallistos Ware's The Orthodox Church. Ware begins with the word itself. Christian Tradition, he writes, is “the faith which Jesus Christ imparted to the Apostles, and which since the Apostles' time has been handed down from generation to generation in the Church.” But to an Orthodox Christian the word means something “more concrete and specific than this. It means the books of the Bible; it means the Creed; it means the decrees of the Ecumenical Councils and the writings of the Fathers; it means the Canons, the Service Books, the Holy Icons — in fact, the whole system of doctrine, Church government, worship, and art which Orthodoxy has articulated over the ages.”

Note, Ware insists, that the Bible forms a part of Tradition. “Sometimes Tradition is defined as ‘the oral teaching of Christ, not recorded in writing by his immediate disciples.’” Many writers, Orthodox and not, have spoken that way, “treating Scripture and Tradition as two different things, two distinct sources of the Christian faith. But in reality there is only one source, since Scripture exists within Tradition. To separate and contrast the two is to impoverish the idea of both alike.”

That does not make the Bible one authority among equals. “Among the various elements of Tradition, a unique pre-eminence belongs to the Bible, to the Creed, to the doctrinal definitions of the Ecumenical Councils: these things the Orthodox accept as something absolute and unchanging, something which cannot be cancelled or revised.” The Bible is, Ware writes, “the supreme expression of God's revelation to man, and Christians must always be ‘People of the Book.’ But if Christians are People of the Book, the Bible is the Book of the People; it must not be regarded as something set up over the Church, but as something that lives and is understood within the Church.” And so: “It is from the Church that the Bible ultimately derives its authority, for it was the Church which originally decided which books form a part of Holy Scripture; and it is the Church alone which can interpret Holy Scripture with authority.” A convert received into the Orthodox Church promises: “I will accept and understand Holy Scripture in accordance with the interpretation which was and is held by the Holy Orthodox Catholic Church of the East, our Mother.”

The classical doctrinal statement of the same position is the Confession of Dositheus, ratified by the Synod of Jerusalem in 1672 as the Orthodox answer to the Calvinist-leaning Confession of the Patriarch Cyril Lucaris. Its second decree reads: “We believe the Divine and Sacred Scriptures to be God-taught; and, therefore, we ought to believe the same without doubting; yet not otherwise than as the Catholic Church hath interpreted and delivered the same.” The decree goes on: “Wherefore, the witness also of the Catholic Church is, we believe, not of inferior authority to that of the Divine Scriptures. For one and the same Holy Spirit being the author of both, it is quite the same to be taught by the Scriptures and by the Catholic Church.”

The Orthodox case has its own Scriptures. Paul tells the Thessalonians to “stand firm and hold to the traditions that you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or by our letter” (2 Thessalonians 2:15) — the apostle's own teaching, delivered in speech as well as in writing. He describes the gospel itself in the language of handing on: “I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received” (1 Corinthians 15:3). And the Church, Paul writes, is “the church of the living God, a pillar and buttress of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:15). The classic patristic statement is Basil the Great's, in On the Holy Spirit (27.66): “Of the beliefs and practices whether generally accepted or publicly enjoined which are preserved in the Church some we possess derived from written teaching; others we have received delivered to us ‘in a mystery’ by the tradition of the apostles; and both of these in relation to true religion have the same force.” Basil's examples are the Church's practices — the sign of the cross, facing east in prayer, the blessing of the water of baptism, baptism by threefold immersion — customs, he asks, for which “what writing has taught us?”

2. What Tradition contains — and how it is recognised

Ware lists six outward forms in which Tradition is expressed: Scripture, the Councils, the Fathers, the Liturgy, the Canons and the Icons. “These things are not to be separated and contrasted, for it is the same Holy Spirit which speaks through them all, and together they make up a single whole, each part being understood in the light of the rest.” The doctrinal definitions of the Seven Ecumenical Councils are, in Ware's words, infallible, possessing “along with the Bible, an abiding and irrevocable authority” — above all the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed, read or sung at every celebration of the Eucharist.

But the formulation of doctrine did not stop in 787. Since then the Church has spoken through local councils and through individual bishops — and here Ware is candid about the limits. “While the doctrinal decisions of General Councils are infallible, those of a Local Council or an individual bishop are always liable to error; but if such decisions are accepted by the rest of the Church, then they come to acquire Ecumenical authority.” The Church, he adds, “has often been selective in its treatment of the acts of Local Councils: in the case of the seventeenth century Councils, for example, their statements of faith have in part been received by the whole Orthodox Church, but in part set aside or corrected.” The same selectivity applies to the Fathers: “individual writers have at times fallen into error and at times contradict one another. Patristic wheat needs to be distinguished from Patristic chaff.” The Church, Ware notes, “has never attempted to define exactly who the Fathers are, still less to classify them in order of importance.”

Much of Tradition lives not in definitions but in worship. “Lex orandi lex credendi: men's faith is expressed in their prayer.” Doctrines never formally defined are “yet held by the Church with an unmistakable inner conviction, an unruffled unanimity, which is just as binding as an explicit formulation.” The Canons — the Church's rules of order and discipline, gathered in the Pedalion, the “Rudder” of St Nicodemus of the Holy Mountain (1800) — have a lesser authority than dogma, since they deal with “the earthly life of the Church, where conditions are constantly changing”; yet “in a relative sense the Canons form a part of Holy Tradition.” And the Icons are a part of Tradition too: through them, Ware writes, “the Orthodox Christian receives a vision of the spiritual world.”

Orthodoxy draws a line inside its own inheritance — between Tradition and traditions. “Not everything received from the past is of equal value, nor is everything received from the past necessarily true.” Ware quotes a bishop at the Council of Carthage: “The Lord said, ‘I am truth.’ He did not say, I am custom.” Many things handed down are “human and accidental — pious opinions (or worse), but not a true part of the one Tradition, the essential Christian message.” And Tradition itself is not a museum piece. Ware quotes Georges Florovsky: “Tradition is the witness of the Spirit… Tradition is not only a protective, conservative principle; it is, primarily, the principle of growth and regeneration.” Tradition, Ware writes, “is not only kept by the Church — it lives in the Church, it is the life of the Holy Spirit in the Church.”

How, then, is true Tradition recognised? The classic test is the Vincentian canon, set down by Vincent of Lérins in his Commonitorium (434): hold “that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, by all” — quod ubique, quod semper, quod ab omnibus creditum est. Universality, antiquity, consent. Vincent himself looked first to the authority of Scripture, and next to the tradition of the Church — tradition as the guide to Scripture's meaning, not a rival to it. And the Eastern Patriarchs, answering Pope Pius IX in their Encyclical of 1848, put the guarding of the faith in the hands of the whole Church: “neither Patriarchs nor Councils could then have introduced novelties amongst us, because the protector of religion is the very body of the Church, even the people themselves, who desire their religious worship to be ever unchanged and of the same kind as that of their fathers.” A century earlier, writing to the English Non-Jurors in 1718, the Patriarchs had said the same in shorter form: “We preserve the Doctrine of the Lord uncorrupted… neither adding any thing, nor taking any thing from it.”

Even so, the edges are not all settled. The Old Testament canon is a case in point. The Septuagint contains ten further books beyond the Hebrew thirty-nine, and the Councils of Jassy (1642) and Jerusalem (1672) declared them “genuine parts of Scripture.” Yet, as Ware records, “most Orthodox scholars at the present day, however, following the opinion of Athanasius and Jerome, consider that the Deutero-Canonical Books, although part of the Bible, stand on a lower footing than the rest of the Old Testament.”

3. What Scripture says

There is common ground first, and it matters. The evangelical does not deny that the faith is handed on: Paul's own words are “I delivered to you… what I also received.” No Christian reads the Bible without teachers, and no church lives without customs. The disagreement is not about whether tradition exists, but about whether it can stand beside Scripture as an authority of equal weight — and about who decides what counts as Tradition when the traditions disagree.

The first difference is sufficiency. Paul tells Timothy that “from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings, which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus” (2 Timothy 3:15). Then the claim: “All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16–17). Complete: nothing missing, nothing to add. If Scripture makes the man of God complete for every good work, then whatever Tradition adds must either already be in Scripture — in which case it adds nothing — or stand outside it, in which case the addition needs a warrant Scripture itself does not give.

Paul goes further still. The gospel the Galatians had received was the standard by which even an apostle must be judged: “But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed” (Galatians 1:8). Paul submits himself — and an angel — to the message already delivered. And Scripture closes the door on additions from the beginning: “You shall not add to the word that I command you, nor take from it” (Deuteronomy 4:2); “Do not add to his words, lest he rebuke you and you be found a liar” (Proverbs 30:6). A Tradition that adds doctrines Scripture nowhere states is not completing the word; it is doing what the word forbids.

The second difference is the warning. Jesus' sharpest words about tradition are in Mark 7, where the Pharisees kept a received custom — Corban, dedicating to God what a parent needed — and by it set aside the commandment to honour father and mother. “You leave the commandment of God and hold to the tradition of men” (Mark 7:8). “You have a fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in order to establish your tradition!” (Mark 7:9). The result: “thus making void the word of God by your tradition that you have handed down” (Mark 7:13). The tradition in question was not obviously corrupt; it was pious, even generous — a gift to God. That is the point. A tradition can be ancient, sincere and widely kept, and still void the word. Tradition therefore needs a judge outside itself, and Scripture claims to be that judge.

The third difference is the contradictions — not between Orthodoxy and the evangelical, but inside Orthodoxy's own account. The Vincentian canon promises a test: what has been believed everywhere, always, by all. But the Church's own history fails it. The veneration of icons was not believed everywhere, always, by all: for over a century the Church was divided over it, and two councils calling themselves the Seventh Ecumenical Council anathematised each other's position. The number of the sacraments was not believed everywhere, always, by all either: earlier writers counted two, six, ten — John of Damascus two, Dionysius the Areopagite six, Joasaph of Ephesus ten — and the list of seven was fixed only in the seventeenth century, from the Latin West, in the Orthodox Confession of Peter Mogila (1640) and the Confession of Dositheus (1672). The 1718 letter's claim — “neither adding any thing, nor taking any thing from it” — sits against Ware's own account: the formulation of doctrine “did not cease with the Seventh Ecumenical Council,” and Tradition is “constantly assuming new forms.” Something was added, and Ware says so himself.

The canon of Scripture fails the test too. Ware claims the Church “originally decided which books form a part of Holy Scripture.” But no Ecumenical Council ever issued a list of the books of Scripture. The closest the Church came was the Council in Trullo (692), whose second canon ratified several lists at once — Athanasius's, Carthage's, Laodicea's, the Apostolic Canons — and the lists disagree: Athanasius puts the deuterocanonical books outside the canon proper, Carthage counts them in. The New Testament list is agreed; the Old Testament list is not. The Church that claims to have decided the canon has never agreed on which Old Testament books are in it. And the Fathers disagree with each other. Justin Martyr and Irenaeus taught a literal thousand-year reign of Christ on earth — Justin wrote that he and “others who are right-minded Christians on all points are assured that there will be a resurrection of the dead, and a thousand years in Jerusalem” (Dialogue with Trypho, 80) — while Justin himself admitted that “many who belong to the pure and pious faith, and are true Christians, think otherwise.” The later Church set the chiliast teaching aside. So the Fathers disagreed in their own day, and the Church later chose between them — which means the Fathers cannot be the final court, because something else did the choosing.

The fourth difference is who decides. The Vincentian canon promises a test — everywhere, always, by all — but it does not say who applies it, and history shows the test is harder to apply than to state. In 754 a council of 338 bishops met at Hieria, called itself the Seventh Ecumenical Council, and condemned the making and veneration of icons. Thirty-three years later the Second Council of Nicaea (787) read Hieria's decree aloud, answered it point by point, and annulled it; Hieria is now remembered as a robber council. The same Church, the same Fathers, the same appeal to Tradition — and opposite anathemas within a generation. No patriarch attended Hieria — the see of Constantinople was vacant, and Rome, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem were unrepresented — and that absence is part of why it was never received. But the point stands: the test of reception is retrospective. For a generation, the Church's own mechanism could not settle the question in the moment — the verdict came only afterwards. Ware himself concedes the point in principle: the Church has been “selective” with the acts of local councils, receiving some decisions and setting others aside. But if the Church can set aside its own councils, then “the Church decides” is not an answer; it is the question restated. And the argument runs in a circle: the Church authenticates Tradition, and Tradition authenticates the Church. Each appeals to the other, and neither stands outside the other to judge it. The appeal to “the Church” also assumes what needs proving — which communion is the Church? The churches that rejected Chalcedon in 451, the Coptic, Armenian and Syriac churches, claim the same Fathers and the same Tradition as the Chalcedonians, and each side calls the other the breakaway. The Vincentian canon cannot settle it: both sides claim universality, antiquity and consent. Who decides which decisions stand? The Fathers raise the same problem: if “Patristic wheat needs to be distinguished from Patristic chaff,” the winnowing needs a sieve. Scripture offers itself as that sieve. The Bereans were called “more noble” precisely because they tested even an apostle's preaching: they “received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so” (Acts 17:11).

The fifth difference is how far the principle reaches. Basil's examples are mostly the Church's practices — the sign of the cross, facing east, the baptismal customs — though he presses the point as far as the confession of faith itself. No evangelical denies that the Church has customs Scripture does not prescribe. The question is whether “the same force” that Basil claims for a practice extends to doctrines — and to doctrines Scripture nowhere states. The same question returns with the canon. The evangelical answer is that the Church recognised the canon; it did not create it. A council does not make a book Scripture by voting for it. The books were received because they bore the voice of the apostles — a voice the Church hears in Scripture, not one it lends to it.

There is a deeper question behind all of this: who may read and judge? Ware says it is “the Church alone which can interpret Holy Scripture with authority.” But Scripture speaks to the simple, not only to the learned: “The unfolding of your words gives light; it imparts understanding to the simple” (Psalm 119:130). The duty of testing belongs to every believer: “do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God” (1 John 4:1). And Jesus himself answered the religious establishment of his day — the men who held the tradition — with “Have you not read…?” (Matthew 22:31), treating Scripture as the court of appeal over the tradition, not under it. “Scripture cannot be broken” (John 10:35) — not by a council, not by a Father, not by a Church.

Why it matters — three questions

None of this is abstract. For someone considering Orthodoxy, it is the question of what they would actually be submitting to — not one book, but a whole inheritance, and a Church that claims the sole right to interpret it. Three questions are worth carrying into that decision.

Who decides what counts as Tradition? If the test is reception by the whole Church, and reception takes decades and sometimes reverses — as it did between Hieria and Nicaea — how does a believer know, today, which traditions are Tradition and which are only traditions? And when the councils anathematised each other, the canon lists disagree and the Fathers contradict one another, who sorts the wheat from the chaff?

Can tradition ever be tested — and by what? Jesus warned that tradition can make void the word of God. The Bereans tested an apostle's preaching against the Scriptures and were praised for it. If Scripture cannot judge tradition, what can? And if only the Church may interpret Scripture, who tests the Church?

Is Scripture enough? Paul says the sacred writings make the man of God complete, equipped for every good work. God forbade adding to his word. If something must be added to them, the addition needs a warrant — and the warrant has to come from somewhere Scripture itself does not provide.

That is the conversation this series exists for.

Sources: Kallistos Ware, The Orthodox Church (3rd ed., Penguin, 1993), ch. “Holy Tradition: The Source of the Orthodox Faith” — the chapter this piece follows throughout, including the passage it quotes from Georges Florovsky (“Sobornost: the Catholicity of the Church,” in The Church of God, ed. E. L. Mascall) and the Letter of the Eastern Patriarchs to the Non-Jurors (1718) as Ware cites it; the Confession of Dositheus, Decree 2, ratified by the Synod of Jerusalem (1672), in the translation of J. N. W. B. Robertson, The Acts and Decrees of the Synod of Jerusalem (1899); the Encyclical of the Eastern Patriarchs (1848), §17, in the classic English translation; Vincent of Lérins, Commonitorium 2 (434), in the translation of C. A. Heurtley (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 11); Basil the Great, On the Holy Spirit 27.66, in the translation of Blomfield Jackson (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 8); the Council of Hieria (754) as surveyed in the standard histories and in the excursus on the council in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 14; the Council in Trullo (692), canon 2, and the canon lists it ratified — the Apostolic Canons, the Synod of Laodicea, the Third Synod of Carthage (397) and the 39th Festal Letter of Athanasius (367) — which do not agree with each other; Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 80, and Irenaeus, Against Heresies, book 5, for the chiliast teaching of the early Fathers; the Orthodox Confession of Peter Mogila (1640), Q98, ratified at the Synod of Jassy (1642), and the Confession of Dositheus, Decree 15, for the sevenfold list of sacraments, with the earlier variation in the number surveyed in the Encyclopædia Britannica's article on Eastern Orthodoxy and in OrthodoxWiki's “Holy Mysteries.” Honest limits: the Ware quotations follow the published text of the chapter as circulated in the booklet of excerpts of Part II, cross-checked against independent postings of the same passages; this piece is built from the published texts named, not from a fresh reading of Ware's book in full or of the Greek originals; Scripture references are quoted from the English Standard Version.

Related reading: What Orthodoxy teaches about salvation — on salvation; What Orthodoxy teaches about the toll-houses — on the toll-houses, the soul's passage after death; Orthodox soteriology, from an Evangelical perspective — four talks by Rev. Giotis Kantartzis on salvation in Orthodox theology, with video, timestamped main points and English subtitles; Ecclesiology — nine talks by Sotiris Boukis on what the Church is; In dialogue with Orthodoxy — the series this piece belongs to.

Researched and drafted with the help of Muse, an AI assistant. Every claim is checked against its sources, and every article is approved by Aris Angelakopoulos before publication.