Ekklisia

English · Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά →

What Orthodoxy teaches about icons

22 November 2026 · 14 min read

In the “What Orthodoxy teaches” series — for anyone thinking of becoming Orthodox, and for evangelicals who want to understand their Orthodox neighbours.

Icons are the first thing a visitor notices in an Orthodox church, and the hardest thing to miss. They cover the walls, they stand in a screen before the sanctuary, they hang in the narthex where worshippers stop to kiss them and light a candle before them. For an evangelical walking in, the sight raises the sharpest question in this whole series: is this veneration, or is it idolatry? The Orthodox answer is that the question itself rests on a confusion — between worship and veneration, between the image and the person it shows. This piece states that answer first, fairly and from its own sources, and then asks what Scripture says.

Icons are not a side issue in Orthodoxy. They are, as the Church's own feast says, the triumph of Orthodoxy itself.

1. The Incarnation, and what may be honoured

The Orthodox defence of icons begins not with art but with the Incarnation. Its classic statement comes from John of Damascus (c. 675–749), writing from beyond the emperor's reach while the icons were under attack. Of old, he says, God could not be depicted at all; but now “when God is seen clothed in flesh, and conversing with men, I make an image of the God whom I see. I do not worship matter, I worship the God of matter, who became matter for my sake, and deigned to inhabit matter, who worked out my salvation through matter. I will not cease from honouring that matter which works my salvation. I venerate it, though not as God.” The argument turns on a single change: God, who could not be depicted, has been seen. What was impossible before the Incarnation is possible after it — because the invisible God has a visible face.

The same point is made by the image itself. Damascus makes it again in his Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith (IV.16): when a worshipper looks at an image of the Crucifixion, “his saving passion is brought back to remembrance, and we fall down and worship not the material but that which is imaged: just as we do not worship the material of which the Gospels are made, nor the material of the Cross, but that which these typify.” The icon, on this account, does what the written word does: it brings the saving event to mind. Nobody supposes the worshipper adores the paper of the Gospel book; the honour passes through the material to what it signifies.

That passing-through is the heart of the Orthodox position, and it rests on a distinction the Church insists on with great care: between latreia, the worship that belongs to God alone, and timetike proskynesis, the veneration of honour paid to holy persons and things. The distinction was defined by the Second Council of Nicaea in 787, the Seventh Ecumenical Council, in words that still govern Orthodox practice: “we with all exactness and care do define that, in the same manner as the Holy and Life-giving Cross, so shall holy images, whether formed of colours or of stones, or any other convenient material, be set forth in all the holy churches of God, and also on sacred vessels and garments, on walls and doors, in houses and by the highways, whether images of Christ Jesus our Lord, our God and Saviour, or of our spotless Lady, the Holy Mother of God, or of the Holy Angels or of all the Saints and other holy men. For in proportion as these are continually seen by representation in images, so are they who behold them moved to the remembrance of, and affection for, their prototypes.”

The council then drew the line in the same breath: “there be paid to them the worship of salutation and honour, and not that true worship which is according to faith, and which is due to the Divine Nature alone, but such worship as is properly paid to the image of the Holy and Life-giving Cross and to the Holy Gospels, and to the other sacred monuments, and that the offering of incense and lights should be made to the honour of such things as was the pious custom of the ancients. For the honour of the image passes on to the prototype, and those who venerate an image venerate in it the person of him who is represented thereby.” The sentence about the honour passing to the prototype is Basil the Great's, from On the Holy Spirit (18.45): “because the honour paid to the image passes on to the prototype.” The council took it up and made it the rule: the icon is honoured only for the sake of the person it shows, and the honour arrives at the person, not at the wood and paint.

That is the theory. The practice is what the council's own words describe: the images are kissed, and incense and candles are offered before them, as before the Cross and the Gospels. An icon of Christ stands at the centre; beside him his Mother, the Theotokos, most often shown as the Hodegetria, “she who shows the way”; then the angels and the saints. The icon screen, the iconostasis, carries them across the front of the church. The Orthodox worshipper does not regard any of this as decoration. The icon is a window, not a wall: it opens onto the person, and through the person onto heaven.

Why the Church holds this so fiercely is written into its calendar. The restoration of the icons is kept every year on the first Sunday of Lent, the Sunday of Orthodoxy, when the Synodikon is read — the short profession of the validity of icon veneration, beginning “As the prophets beheld, as the Apostles taught… as the Church received…” The feast is not only about pictures. It celebrates the victory of the true faith over heresy as such. To deny the icon, on the Orthodox account, is to deny the Incarnation it depicts: a Christ who cannot be painted is a Christ who did not truly become man. The council's definition says as much — the making of images is “perfectly concordant with the history of the Evangelical preaching unto the assurance of the true and not the imaginary Incarnation of God the Word.”

2. A century of breaking images

The teaching was not settled without a fight. In 726 the emperor Leo III moved against the veneration of icons, and the controversy raged on and off for more than a century, in two phases: from 726 to 787, and again from 815 to 842. The iconoclasts — the image-breakers — held that the commandment against images forbade them outright, and that the Church's practice was idolatry. In 754 a council of 338 bishops met at Hieria, called itself the Seventh Ecumenical Council, and condemned the making and veneration of icons. Thirty-three years later the Second Council of Nicaea (787) read Hieria's decree aloud, answered it point by point, and annulled it. The council met from 24 September to 23 October 787, under the Empress Irene and at the request of Tarasios, Patriarch of Constantinople, with 367 bishops present; its definition is the text quoted above. It is the last council that both East and West accept as ecumenical.

But Nicaea did not end the matter. The second phase of iconoclasm began in 815, and it was fiercer than the first: monks were persecuted, and the defence was led in that generation by Theodore the Studite (759–826). The controversy was closed for good only in 843, after the death of the last iconoclast emperor, Theophilos. His widow, the Empress Theodora, acting as regent for her young son Michael III, with the Patriarch Methodios, called a synod at Constantinople that reaffirmed Nicaea's decisions and condemned the iconoclast councils of Hieria (754) and Constantinople (815). On 11 March 843, the first Sunday of Lent, the participants processed from the church of the Mother of God at Blachernae to Hagia Sophia, carrying an icon of the Mother of God, and restored the icons to the churches. That procession is still commemorated every year, on the same Sunday, as the Triumph of Orthodoxy.

The history matters for the argument of this series. The veneration of icons was not believed everywhere, always, by all: for over a century the Church was divided over it, and two councils calling themselves the Seventh Ecumenical Council anathematised each other's position. The piece on Scripture and Tradition made that point against the Vincentian canon. Here it is worth adding what the Orthodox side says in reply: that the Church, through Nicaea and then through the restoration of 843, received the icons and set the iconoclasts aside — and that reception, tested over generations, is itself the mark of Tradition. The question the history leaves open is the one the piece on Scripture and Tradition ended on: who decides, and by what, when the Church has anathematised itself?

3. What Scripture says

There is common ground first, and it matters. The evangelical does not deny that God used visible, material things: the tabernacle was furnished with images by God's own command — “you shall make two cherubim of gold” for the mercy seat (Exodus 25:18–20) — and the bronze serpent Moses lifted up in the wilderness healed everyone who looked at it (Numbers 21:8–9). Matter is not evil, and an image is not idolatry by definition. The disagreement is about what is done with the image, and about whom it depicts.

The first difference is the scope of the commandment. “You shall not make for yourself a carved image, or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the LORD your God am a jealous God” (Exodus 20:4–5). The commandment forbids two things: the making and the bowing. The Orthodox answer is that it forbids idols — images of other gods — not images as such, and the cherubim prove it. But the commandment's own words reach further than other gods: any likeness of anything in heaven above. And the reason it gives reaches back to the day at Horeb: “Since you saw no form on the day that the LORD spoke to you at Horeb out of the midst of the fire, beware lest you act corruptly by making a carved image for yourselves, in the form of any figure” (Deuteronomy 4:15–16). The people had seen fire and cloud and heard a voice — but no form. The ban rests on that absence: God gave them no form to picture.

The golden calf shows how the ban bites. Aaron's calf was not presented as a foreign god. The people said of it, “These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up out of the land of Egypt!” — and Aaron built an altar before it and proclaimed, “Tomorrow shall be a feast to the LORD” (Exodus 32:4–5). The calf was an image of the true God, made for the worship of the true God, and it was condemned all the same. The Orthodox distinction — the honour passes through the image to the person — is exactly what Aaron's worship claimed to do. Scripture's verdict on it was not that the honour failed to pass through, but that the image itself was the sin. An image of the true God, honoured for the sake of the true God, is still a breach of the commandment.

The second difference is the bronze serpent. It is the one image in Scripture that God himself commanded, and it worked: everyone bitten who looked at it lived. Yet centuries later, when the people of Israel “had made offerings to it,” Hezekiah “broke in pieces the bronze serpent that Moses had made” (2 Kings 18:4) — and the breaking is listed among his reforms, beside removing the high places and cutting down the Asherah. A God-given image became an idol the moment offerings were made to it, and the faithful king's answer was to destroy it, not to explain the distinction to the people. But offerings before an image are precisely what the council's definition prescribes: “the offering of incense and lights should be made to the honour of such things.” Hezekiah's precedent cuts the other way: when incense is offered to an image, the image goes.

The third difference is the acts themselves. The distinction between worship and veneration is real in the books, and the theologians state it with care. But in the church, the acts are the same acts Scripture reserves for God: bowing down, kissing, candles, incense, processions carrying the image aloft. The question is not whether a theologian can distinguish the two kinds of honour, but whether the worshipper's body can — and whether Scripture lets the distinction carry the weight it is asked to carry. When John fell down to worship the angel, the angel did not correct his intention and accept a lesser honour: “You must not do that! I am a fellow servant with you and your brothers who hold to the testimony of Jesus. Worship God” (Revelation 19:10). The angel was a holy creature and a fellow servant, not an idol — and the refusal was absolute. Paul makes the same point in Athens: “Being then God's offspring, we ought not to think that the divine being is like gold or silver or stone, an image formed by the art and imagination of man” (Acts 17:29). And the pattern of Romans 1 is the exchange itself: “Claiming to be wise, they became fools, and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images resembling mortal man and birds and animals and creeping things” (Romans 1:22–23).

The fourth difference is the Incarnation argument itself — the strongest in the Orthodox case, and the one that deserves the fairest hearing. John of Damascus is right that something changed when God was seen in the flesh. But the change Scripture records is not that images became lawful; it is that the image is a person. “He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation” (Colossians 1:15). Christ himself is the image — not a painting of him. And the apostles, who had seen him, heard him and handled him, never made an image of him and never told the churches to. The worship of the New Testament has no images in it: “God is spirit, and those who worship him must worship in spirit and truth” (John 4:24). The Incarnation gives the Church a visible Saviour to proclaim, not a visible face to paint and kiss.

There is a further precision, and it comes from Basil himself. The sentence the council borrowed — “the honour paid to the image passes on to the prototype” — was written about the king's image, and about the Son as the image of the Father. Basil's own words draw the line the council's use of them blurs: “what in the one case the image is by reason of imitation, that in the other case the Son is by nature.” The Son is the image by nature; a painted panel is an image by imitation. Basil's sentence works for the Son precisely because the Son is not a copy. Applied to a panel, it proves less than it is asked to prove: that honour can pass from a copy to its original is the claim, not the evidence for it — and the golden calf is the evidence against it.

Why it matters — three questions

None of this is abstract. For someone considering Orthodoxy, the icons are the first thing they will do, week by week: stop before an image, bow, kiss it, light a candle. Three questions are worth carrying into that decision.

If the calf was condemned, what makes an image of Christ different? Aaron's calf pictured the true God and was honoured for his sake. The commandment forbade the making and the bowing alike. If the Orthodox distinction answers the calf, it must show where the calf's worship differs from the veneration of an icon — in the act, not only in the intention.

If Hezekiah broke the bronze serpent, what should be done with an image before which incense is offered? The serpent was commanded by God and it healed. It became an idol when offerings were made to it, and the reforming king broke it. The council prescribes incense and lights before the icons. Which precedent governs — the making, or the breaking?

Who decides where veneration ends and worship begins? The theologian's distinction is clear on the page. But the worshipper bows, kisses, lights a candle and carries the image in procession — the very acts the commandment names. If the distinction lives only in the explanation, and not in the act, is it the worshipper who venerates, or the theologian who explains?

That is the conversation this series exists for.

Sources: The Definition of the Second Council of Nicaea (787), in the translation printed in The Seventh General Council and the Doctrine of Icons (London: SPCK, 1919; Project Canterbury), cross-checked against H. R. Percival's translation (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 14); John of Damascus, On Holy Images, I.16, in the translation of Mary H. Allies (London, 1898), and the passage on the image of the Crucifixion from his Exact Exposition of the Orthodox Faith, IV.16, in the translation of S. D. F. Salmond (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 9); Basil the Great, On the Holy Spirit 18.45, in the translation of Blomfield Jackson (Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 2nd series, vol. 8); the Triumph of Orthodoxy (843) — the Synod of Constantinople, the procession of 11 March 843 from Blachernae to Hagia Sophia, and the Sunday of Orthodoxy — as recorded by the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America (goarch.org, “The First Sunday of Lent: The Sunday of Orthodoxy”) and in the standard histories; the Council of Hieria (754) as in the piece on Scripture and Tradition. Honest limits: this piece is built from the published texts named, not from a fresh reading of Ware's The Orthodox Church in full or of the Greek originals; no quotation from Ware is used, and the piece does not rely on his chapter; the Nicaea II quotations follow the SPCK 1919 translation, cross-checked against Percival's translation in NPNF2-14; Scripture references are quoted from the English Standard Version.

Related reading: What Orthodoxy teaches about salvation — on salvation; What Orthodoxy teaches about the toll-houses — on the toll-houses, the soul's passage after death; What Orthodoxy teaches about Scripture and Tradition — on Scripture and Tradition; The priesthood of all believers — a companion piece in “The royal priesthood” series; The man who wrote to the Patriarch — the story of Charalampakis, whose letters began with the procession of the Axion Esti icon; In dialogue with Orthodoxy — the series this piece belongs to.

Researched and drafted with the help of Muse, an AI assistant. Every claim is checked against its sources, and every article is approved by Aris Angelakopoulos before publication.