Ekklisia

English · Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά →

What Orthodoxy teaches about the Holy Light

22 November 2026 · 18 min read

In the “What Orthodoxy teaches” series — for anyone thinking of becoming Orthodox, and for evangelicals who want to understand their Orthodox neighbours.

Every year on Holy Saturday, in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, the Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem enters the tomb of Christ alone and comes out carrying fire. It is called the Holy Light — in Greek, Ἅγιο Φῶς — and also the Holy Fire. Within hours it is flown to Athens, received with head-of-state honours, and carried to churches across the Orthodox world, from Georgia and Romania to Russia and, since 2017, the United States. The claim, made for centuries, is that the fire comes down from heaven: that the Patriarch enters with unlit candles, prays, and the cotton placed on the tomb lights by itself — and that the flame does not burn the skin of those who touch it. This piece states that claim first, fairly and from the tradition's own sources, and then looks at what the Patriarchate itself has said and done about it, and at what Scripture says.

The Holy Light is not a marginal devotion. For Orthodox Christians it is the yearly visible sign of the Resurrection itself — the moment the Church points to and says: here is the proof. That is what makes the story of this piece worth telling carefully: the claim is believed, it is defended, and it is the claim the Patriarchate itself has stopped making.

1. What the Church has claimed for centuries

The ceremony, as the tradition describes it, runs like this. On Great Saturday — the day before Orthodox Easter — the tomb is searched beforehand, by clergy of the other churches that share the Holy Sepulchre, to certify that no lit lamp or other source of light is hidden inside. The Patriarch is searched too, to make sure he carries nothing that could light a flame. He then enters the Edicule, the small chapel over the tomb, alone, holding two bunches of unlit candles. He kneels before the tomb and prays. Then, the tradition says, fire descends from heaven and lights the lamp over the tomb; a piece of cotton placed on the tomb lights by itself; the Patriarch lights his candles from it and comes out to the waiting crowds. The flame, it is said, does not burn skin or hair for the first minutes — thirty-three minutes, in some accounts — and other lamps and candles in the church are said to light spontaneously.

The prayer the Patriarch reads speaks of receiving light “from the light burning continually and ever-shining on this your light-bearing Tomb”. A lamp is kept in the tomb — the “Sleepless Candle”, the ἀκοίμητη κανδήλα — which, on the traditional account, burns perpetually. A former Patriarch of Jerusalem, Diodoros, described it like this: “From the core of the very stone on which Jesus lay an indefinable light pours forth. It usually has a blue tint…”

The claim has a long history behind it. Eusebius, in the fourth century, told of a paschal vigil when the oil failed and the water Narcissus ordered into the lamps was changed into oil. The pilgrim Egeria, around 385, described light coming forth from the chapel — though, honestly, she describes no miracle. By 867 Bernard the Wise wrote of an angel lighting the lamps above the tomb. Ibn al-Qass, writing before 946, told of a white flame that did not burn, in a tomb locked with no one inside. The Muslim scholar al-Biruni, writing a century later, recorded lamps on the sealed tomb lighting of themselves: “The coming that day of the fire from the sky... is cause for us to be in awe.” The emperor John VI Kantakouzenos wrote of light descending from heaven — κατέρχεται φῶς οὐρανόθεν. And Chrysanthos of Prousa, in 1837, described the Patriarch entering alone and beholding “wondrously the holy light upon the holy tomb”.

The fire does not stay in Jerusalem. Until 1988 it reached Greece by ship, a week after Holy Saturday; since then it has been flown in by special flight on the day itself, and since 2001 it has been received in Athens with head-of-state honours. It travels on to Georgia, Ukraine, Romania and Russia, and in 2017 it was carried to the United States for the first time. And the claim is still believed: in a 2019 poll, about four in ten Greeks said the lighting was miraculous, about four in ten that it was a human lighting blessed by the Patriarch, and about two in ten were undecided. This is the claim as Orthodox believers have been taught it, and as many still hold it. The rest of this piece is about what the Patriarchate itself has done with it.

2. The wording change

Until the summer of 2018, the Jerusalem Patriarchate's official website carried a chapter called “The Holy Light”, describing the ceremony in full. The text is preserved in the Wayback Machine, in a snapshot of 19 June 2018. It opened with the claim stated in the strongest possible terms: “It is about a real miracle that leaves no room for doubt.” The Greek read: «Πρόκειται διὰ ἀληθινὸν θαῦμα, τὸ ὁποῖον δὲν χωρᾶ καμιὰν ἀμφισβήτησιν».

The old text then set out the whole traditional account, point by point. The tomb had been searched: “It is necessary to note that the heterodox have already carefully examined the interior of the Holy Edicule, to ensure there are no lit oil lamps or any other source of light.” The Patriarch had been searched: “The heterodox examine the Patriarch to ensure he has nothing on Him that could arouse or draw suspicion.” He entered “holding two bunches of unlit candles”. And then: “After this blessing he places a piece of cotton on the Holy Tomb and miraculously it lights up. With it the Patriarch lights the candles and exits the Holy Edicule. The amazing thing is that the holy light for a few minutes does not burn. Namely, if someone touches his hands with the holy light he will not get burnt. Truly this is one of the greatest Miracles of Christianity that repeats every year on Great Saturday.”

Between the snapshot of 19 June 2018 and the next, on 26 July, that text was replaced wholesale. In its place the Patriarchate posted a ceremonial description from 1911, taken from a book called “The Flowers of Paradise” (ΤΑ ΑΝΘΗ ΤΟΥ ΠΑΡΑΔΕΙΣΟΥ) — a description of the order of the rite, in an Ottoman-era setting, in which the word “miracle” never appears at all. In the new text the Patriarch enters the tomb, kneels, prays — and then simply “takes the holy light” (λαμβάνει τό ἅγιον φῶς). How the light was lit is not stated. The event is called a “mysterious ceremony” and a “sacred ceremony”, and its appearance is described — but the mechanism, the search, the unlit candles and the non-burning flame are all gone. The journalist who investigated the change, Dimitris Alikakos, dates the swap to 23 June 2018; an Athens court decision corroborates that the word “miracle” was removed and another text posted, with the Patriarch's agreement — though the exact day cannot be fixed from the snapshots alone.

The English page was never reworded at all. It still carried the old miracle text in a snapshot of 28 December 2018, six months after the Greek page had changed; it was then removed — some time between that snapshot and August 2019 — and its address now redirects to a news post from 2015. Today there is no descriptive Holy Fire page on the Patriarchate's website at all: the chapter has been deleted from both the Greek and the English sites, and the English Holy Sepulchre page returns a “page not found”. What remains is the annual ceremony announcement. The most recent, dated 12 April 2026, says only that the Patriarch, having prayed, “imparted the Light of Christ's Resurrection from the Holy Tomb” — and that the faithful “touched it to their eyes, lips, and foreheads”. No miracle. No descent. No ignition. No unlit candles. No search. No flame that does not burn. Nothing of the miraculous mechanism survives in the Patriarchate's own wording.

3. What prompted it, and what the Church's own people say

The change did not come out of nowhere. On 10 March 2018, the Armenian Bishop Samuel Agoyan, whose Church shares the Holy Sepulchre, said on Israeli television that during his participation the Greek Patriarch had ignited the fire with the assistance of a lamp. A month later, on 12 April, the journalist Dimitris Alikakos telephoned the Patriarchate's Chief Secretariat and asked about the “miracle” wording on the official website. The Chief Secretary, Archbishop Aristarchos, told him: “We don't use the word miracle on our website.” Alikakos emailed him the posted excerpt the same day. A week later, on 19 April, in a forty-one-minute telephone call, Aristarchos said he had informed the Patriarch, who had agreed to change the text: “The word miracle will be removed.” By late May an older text had been found to replace it, with the Patriarch's approval, and by early June it was ready to be uploaded.

On 3 July 2018 Alikakos met Patriarch Theophilos III himself, for about half an hour. What follows is Alikakos's account of a private meeting, not a public statement, and it should be read as such. According to Alikakos, the Patriarch said the old text “should not have been there; I don't know how it got there”; that “the Patriarchate does not speak of a miracle”; and, in the end, that “there is no miracle”.

The most direct testimony came from the man who tends the lamp. Archbishop Isidoros of Hierapolis, the skevophylax — the guardian of the Holy Sepulchre — carries the “Sleepless Candle” into the tomb on Holy Saturday morning. In July 2018, in a filmed interview with Alikakos, he said: “Listen. The lamp goes in unlit by me, the whole world sees it on their television. But when the Patriarch enters the Holy Sepulchre, he finds it lit. I light it. With a lighter, what else?” He also lights a second lamp, as a fail-safe. Asked whether the way the flame is created is a miracle, he answered: “No, of course it is not a miracle.” The Athens court that later heard the case found it a true fact that, in July 2018, Isidoros admitted the lighting of the lamp “is done by himself in a natural way, namely with a lighter”. His predecessor as skevophylax, Archbishop Nikiforos, said the same — using matches.

Isidoros was not alone. Metropolitan Kornilios of Petra, who had performed the lighting himself in 2001 as locum tenens, had said as early as that year that the miracle is “the consecration of the natural light from the already-lit lamp”. In 2018 he told Alikakos: “I know that I found the lamp lit and I left it lit. A miracle by appointment every year doesn't happen.” Archbishop Theophanes of Gerasa, a former Exarch of the Holy Sepulchre in Athens, said: “We deceive the believers letting them believe that it is a miracle. This is unacceptable, it does not honor us.” And Professor Konstantinos Kalokyris, who has written a book on the Church of the Resurrection and the Holy Fire, pointed out that nowhere in the prayer of the Holy Light is there any mention, “not even a hint”, of light descending from above — only natural light, lit in remembrance of the Risen Christ.

Doubts, in fact, are not new. In 1238 Pope Gregory IX denounced the ceremony as fraud and forbade the Franciscans to take any part in it; his letter quotes the canons of the Sepulchre saying that “fire from heaven descends into the Sepulchre on Easter eve” and answers that “the Lord... does not need our lies”. In 1775 the Greek scholar and theologian Nikephoros Theotokis, later Archbishop of Slaviansk and Kherson, wrote that senior churchmen of Jerusalem had told him the hierarch “strikes the flint and produces fire above the life-giving Tomb” — and that “no one dares to tell them otherwise, being afraid of suffering something terrible”, so the clergy “remain silent by way of ecclesiastical economy”. In 1825 Adamantios Korais, the leading voice of the Greek Enlightenment, called the ceremony “machinations of fraudulent priests”: no true religion, he argued, needs false miracles, and the ceremony kept Greeks in superstition while Europe built schools and academies; the clergy, he wrote, had inherited a rich workshop and, instead of closing it, increased the merchandise and multiplied the buyers. And Bishop Porphyrius Uspensky, who founded the Russian Mission in Jerusalem, wrote in his diaries that the patriarchal chaplain, Bishop Dionysius of Philadelphia (later Metropolitan of Bethlehem), had confessed the stratagem to him — a lamp hidden behind a movable marble icon — and called the whole thing a “pious falsehood”, adding that the clergy could not end it because the people would “tear us to pieces in front of the very chapel of the Holy Sepulchre”.

The responses to these men are worth hearing, because they show what the defence of the tradition actually rests on. To Gregory, there is no recorded Greek answer: the Latin Church withdrew from the ceremony, and the Greeks carried on without him. To Korais, Konstantinos Oikonomos replied that he had borrowed his evidence silently from the monk Neophytos Kavsokalyvites — who wrote that Patriarch Ephraim II of Jerusalem had told a man in Bucharest that he had abolished the “handmade mechanism” of the Holy Light as a fraud — and hidden his source; and Fr. George Metallinos argues the testimony is unreliable, since no written statement of Ephraim survives and Ephraim himself promoted the pilgrimage. To Uspensky, the standard reply is that his account is third-hand — Porphyrius heard it from Dionysius, who heard it from Archbishop Misail — and that another pilgrim, Hieromonk Melety, spoke to Misail himself and heard him describe the miracle in full. But notice what none of these replies does: none of them denies what the tradition claimed. The defences attack the witnesses — their sources, their character, their distance from the event — while the claim itself, the fire descending from heaven, stands exactly as Gregory quoted it. The doubts are, in that sense, proof of the tradition: you cannot denounce a fraud unless someone is claiming the miracle.

The Patriarchate's response to all this was legal, not theological. In 2019 it sued Alikakos and his publisher, criminally and civilly, for defamation, breach of confidentiality and violations of personal data. Its stated reasons were two: the book was, in its words, “the product of fictional stories invented by the author with the obvious aim of scandalizing the faithful and obtaining financial benefit from the sales of the book”; and the video interviews — including Isidoros's lighter admission — had been recorded without consent and fraudulently edited. The civil claim sought €700,000 in moral damages, and a separate case was brought against Google to have the YouTube video removed. Its public statement said the official position on the ceremony is “that which is contained in the programme of the ceremony of the Holy Light of Great Saturday of each year, on the website of the Patriarchate, in the studies of Hagiotaphite Fathers... and in what is deduced from Holy Scripture and the Fathers of the Church” — a definition that neither asserts nor denies a miracle, and does not address the wording change at all.

The cases failed. On 29 March 2024 Alikakos was acquitted of all criminal charges in Athens, and a civil decision (738/2024) rejected the lawsuits as essentially unfounded. An Athens court also ruled that the Isidoros video had been filmed with his consent. Alikakos said afterwards that the video testimonies had been heard in court, “where they confess that the Holy Fire lights up naturally”. Then, in February 2026, a further decision (2611/2026) rejected a suit by Archbishop Aristarchos and ruled that the lighting of the Holy Fire “is the result of human intervention”; it became final in June 2026, when no appeal was lodged. That decision should be read with care: it has not been covered in the mainstream Greek press, and its corroboration rests on Alikakos's own publication of the decision text. The Patriarchate has issued no public statement about the wording change itself, or about the acquittal, or about the 2026 decision.

4. What Scripture says

Scripture does not ask believers to accept a wonder on authority. It commands the opposite: “Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world” (1 John 4:1). “Test everything; hold fast what is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21). Testing is not unbelief. It is obedience — and it is the test the Holy Fire claim has now been put to, by the Church's own custodians and by a court of law.

Moses gave Israel the test for a claim made in God's name: “when a prophet speaks in the name of the LORD, if the word does not come to pass or come true, that is a word that the LORD has not spoken; the prophet has spoken it presumptuously. You need not be afraid of him” (Deuteronomy 18:22). A claim that must be withdrawn when examined is not strengthened by centuries of repetition — the years do not turn a word the LORD has not spoken into one he has. The Holy Fire claim was examined, by the Armenian bishop's statement, by a journalist's questions, and by the testimony of the men who tend the lamp; and the Patriarchate's own answer was to take the miracle claim off its website, without a word of explanation.

The Holy Fire is also the clearest test of the claim that Tradition stands equal to Scripture. Orthodoxy teaches that Holy Tradition is the life of the Holy Spirit in the Church, and that a true tradition is recognised by the Vincentian canon, set down by Vincent of Lérins: what has been believed everywhere, always, by all. The Holy Fire passes that test. It was believed everywhere, across the whole Orthodox world; always, for a thousand years; and by all — patriarchs, priests, and pilgrims. And it was a man with a lighter. A tradition can be ancient, universal, and unanimous — and wrong. The years do not turn a word the LORD has not spoken into one he has, and neither does the number of the people who believed it.

Scripture also warns that wonders prove nothing by themselves. “For false christs and false prophets will arise and perform great signs and wonders, so as to lead astray, if possible, even the elect” (Matthew 24:24). “The coming of the lawless one is by the activity of Satan with all power and false signs and wonders” (2 Thessalonians 2:9). A wonder, even a real one, is not self-authenticating: the question is never “is it impressive?” but “is it true — and does it agree with the gospel?” A yearly wonder that cannot be examined, in a chamber no one else may enter, fails that question twice over.

The resurrection — the event the Holy Fire is said to prove — was not established by a yearly private wonder in a sealed chamber. Paul lists the witnesses and invites his readers to check them: “he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep” (1 Corinthians 15:6). And before King Agrippa he could say of the whole story of Christ: “this has not been done in a corner” (Acts 26:26). The gospel's evidence is public, checkable, witnessed by hundreds. The Holy Fire's decisive moment happens behind closed doors, in a chamber no one else may enter — and the one man who tends the lamp says he lights it with a lighter. A faith that rests on the resurrection needs no yearly wonder to keep it alive; and a wonder that cannot survive examination is not evidence for the resurrection. It is a burden on it.

Why it matters — three questions

None of this is abstract. For someone considering Orthodoxy, the Holy Light is the proof the Church points to every Easter — and the fire is carried to their own parish, received with honours, and presented as heaven's own witness to the Resurrection. Three questions are worth carrying into that decision.

If the Patriarchate itself removed the miracle claim, what remains of the claim? The old text said the miracle “admits no doubt whatsoever”. The Church that wrote those words took them down without a word of explanation, and its own statement neither asserts nor denies a miracle. What should a believer conclude when the Church withdraws its own proof?

If the lamp is lit by hand, what is the ceremony? The skevophylax says he lights it with a lighter; his predecessor said the same with matches; a metropolitan who performed the lighting himself says a miracle by appointment every year doesn't happen. Is the ceremony a miracle, a symbol, or a custom — and who decides?

What do you do with a sign that fails the test? Scripture says to test everything and hold fast what is good. The test has been run — by the Church's own people, on camera, and in court. What does holding fast to what is good look like when the sign does not survive it?

That is the conversation this series exists for.

Sources: The Jerusalem Patriarchate's official website (jerusalem-patriarchate.info), as preserved in the Wayback Machine: the old “Holy Light” chapter, Greek text (snapshot 19 June 2018) and English text (snapshot 28 December 2018); the replacement 1911 text (snapshots 26 July 2018 and 9 January 2019); the removal of the English page (between 28 December 2018 and 23 August 2019); and the current ceremony announcements (12 April 2026, in Greek and English), with no descriptive page remaining. Dimitris Alikakos's account of his investigation, as published at holyfirethetruth.com and summarised in bankingnews.gr; his book Λύτρωση – Περί του Αγίου Φωτός (Ekremes, 2019). Religion News Service, 29 March 2024 (the acquittal); SEE Check, 11 July 2024 (the Isidoros interview and the dismissal of the lawsuit); KM.RU (the €700,000 civil claim and the Google case); the Athens court decisions 738/2024 and 2611/2026; the Patriarchate's 2019 statement, as quoted by the Orthodoxia news agency (19 March 2019). The historical attestations (Eusebius, Egeria, Bernard the Wise, Ibn al-Qass, al-Biruni, Kantakouzenos, Chrysanthos) and the 2019 poll as collected in the English and Greek Wikipedia articles on the Holy Fire; Patriarch Diodoros's account at holyfire.org. Pope Gregory IX's letter of 1238, as quoted in The Holy Fire and the Divine Photography (ed. Giulio Fanti); Nikephoros Theotokis's letter to Eleutherios Michael the Larisian (1775), as published by K. I. Dyovouniotis from manuscript 1333 of the University Library; Adamantios Korais, “Dialogue concerning the Holy Light in Jerusalem”, in Atakta, vol. III (1825), pp. 327–424; Neophytos Kavsokalyvites's account of Patriarch Ephraim II, and the responses of Konstantinos Oikonomos and Fr. George Metallinos (Photomachika–Antiphotomachika, 2001), as collected at johnsanidopoulos.com; Bishop Porphyrius Uspensky, The Book of My Existence (1896), vol. 3, pp. 299–301, and the Orthodox defence in “In Defense of the Holy Fire” (OrthoChristian, 2008). Honest limits: the exact date of the text swap, 23 June 2018, rests on Alikakos's account and the court decision, within the verified Wayback bracket of 19 June to 26 July 2018; the court decision calls the replacement text a “1910 text” while the page's own colophon says 1911; decision 2611/2026 is corroborated by Alikakos's publication of the decision, not by mainstream-press coverage; the Patriarch's remarks of 3 July 2018 were made in a private meeting reported by Alikakos, not in a public statement; and a second-hand line attributed to decision 2611/2026 on social media is not quoted here. Scripture quotations are from the English Standard Version.

Related reading: What Orthodoxy teaches about salvation — on salvation; What Orthodoxy teaches about the toll-houses — on the toll-houses, the soul's passage after death; What Orthodoxy teaches about Scripture and Tradition — on Scripture and Tradition; What Orthodoxy teaches about the canon of Scripture — on the canon of Scripture; What Orthodoxy teaches about icons — on icons; The priesthood of all believers — a companion piece in “The royal priesthood” series; The man who wrote to the Patriarch — the story of Charalampakis, whose letters began with the procession of the Axion Esti icon; In dialogue with Orthodoxy — the series this piece belongs to.

Researched and drafted with the help of Muse, an AI assistant. Every claim is checked against its sources, and every article is approved by Aris Angelakopoulos before publication.