Ekklisia

English · Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά →

The man who wrote to the Patriarch

21 November 2026 · 9 min read

In a series from the books of Stylianos Charalampakis — a priest who left the priesthood for conscience's sake, and wrote to the Patriarch about it.

Most arguments about the priesthood are made by people with nothing to lose. This one was made by a man who gave up his living for it. Stylianos Charalampakis, an Orthodox priest from Piraeus, served twelve years as a cleric — and then, on 14 February 1955, he defrocked himself. Freely and unforced, in his own words. Not because he had lost his faith, but because his study of the priesthood had led him to a conclusion he could no longer live with as a priest: that there is no “special priesthood” in the Christian dispensation at all.

His book opens with the verse that became his whole argument: “And behold, the curtain of the temple was torn in two, from top to bottom” (Matthew 27:51). The veil is torn, he writes, and that means the mediating priests are abolished — from now on all are welcome into the presence of God. The Christians, he says, are what Scripture calls them: “a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation” (1 Peter 2:9), a kingdom made “priests to his God and Father” (Revelation 1:6). The ancient writers called them the basileion hierateuma — the royal priesthood — and that is the title of his book: The Royal Priesthood, in thirty-three letters to the Ecumenical Patriarch.

The Patriarch's own words

What set him studying was, by his own account, the Patriarch himself. In 1949 a fellow priest, D. Lionakis, handed him a newspaper, the Democratic Press, and said: “Read and see what Patriarch we have. A new Luther. He has in mind to make such reforms in the Church that we will come very close to the Evangelicals.” The paper reported the innovations of the newly elected Ecumenical Patriarch Athenagoras I — and his statement, as Charalampakis reports it, that “dogmatically closest to the Truth are the Protestants.”

Until then, Charalampakis writes, he had been taught that the Evangelical-Protestants were the greatest enemies of Orthodoxy. The Patriarch's reported words overturned everything he had believed — and because they came from the head of the Orthodox Church, he took them seriously. He cut the article out of the newspaper and kept it in his archive. A second saying of the Patriarch's pushed him further: in his farewell address in America, on his election in 1948, Athenagoras had spoken of his intention to help reorganise the Church, and said, in Charalampakis's rendering, “It is time now to add and to take away.” Charalampakis took that to mean that Orthodoxy does not rest entirely on the foundations of the Word of God, and needs revision and reshaping.

So he studied — systematically, he says, and not as the subject is taught in the theological schools. And he came to agree with the judgment he attributes to the Patriarch: that, dogmatically, the Protestants are indeed closest to the truth. “I thank God from my heart,” he writes to Athenagoras, “that you gave me this occasion.” The study cost him his office. On 14 February 1955, “for reasons of conscience and honesty,” he laid aside the cassock, to bring to light what he called the upside-down things of religion — Ta Anapoda tis Thriskeias, the title of his second book — which, as a cleric, he could not do.

Thirty-three letters

He did not go quiet. He began a mimeographed leaflet, Spiritual Echoes (ΠΝΕΥΜΑΤΙΚΟΙ ΑΝΤΙΛΑΛΟΙ), four pages at first, growing into a periodical. The response, he says, was enormous: hundreds of letters of approval from readers of every rank, and priests and hierarchs who read the book and said, “We cannot face these truths.” The leaflets became the book — thirty-three letters, the first thirteen addressed to a priest and a bishop who had answered him, the rest to the Patriarch.

Charalampakis's reply to the priest, which opens the book, is worth hearing, because it is the argument the whole correspondence turns on. He had read the leaflet and replied by setting up the Fathers — Basil, Athanasius, Chrysostom, Gregory, Cyril, Photius — as the only light-bearers, teachers and worshippers of the Christian faith. Charalampakis's answer is firm: some of the Fathers were indeed pious men, but they did not cease to be men, and were therefore always subject to falls and errors. They were not perfect light-bearers. The question is not what the Fathers said, but what Scripture says — and the Fathers themselves, he argues, must be weighed by it.

What turned the correspondence toward the Patriarch was an icon. On 17 April 1963 the monks of Mount Athos brought the Axion Esti icon to Athens and Piraeus, in Charalampakis's words “to strengthen the tendency toward the veneration of icons.” He wrote to the Patriarch — his letter of 22 May 1963 — setting out the responsibility the Patriarch bears, as he saw it, for the unbiblical, cultic veneration of icons. For a year, the Patriarch did not answer.

Letter 14 opens on that silence: “Your silence shows two things: either you adopt what I write, or you despise me.” If the Patriarch adopted his views, Charalampakis writes, he should take courage from the example of Cyril Lucaris, the seventeenth-century Patriarch, in boldness, frankness and honesty. If he despised him, then contempt is no mark of a man in his position — of one who claims to represent Him who said, “whoever comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6:37). And then the invitation, repeated through the book: let us discuss this together. In the book itself, all thirty-three letters are addressed to the Patriarch, “for honour's sake and because of the seriousness of the subject.”

He knew what he was asking for, and what it could cost. His hope for the book, stated in his introduction, is that its contents “will not create religious passions, so that the Christian identity and conduct not be mocked” — and he closes the introduction with Paul's words: “So then let us pursue what makes for peace and for mutual upbuilding” (Romans 14:19).

The replies

The Patriarch did answer — once, and at Christmas. In a letter dated Christmas 1964, Athenagoras I wrote to “the most honourable Mr. St. Charalampakis, our beloved child in the Lord,” thanking him warmly for his festive wishes, which he had received “as a hymn accompanying the angels at the Nativity of the Lord,” and praying that “the grace and rich gifts of the Saviour born in Bethlehem” be upon him and upon his household. It is a warm letter, and a gracious one. It is also, honestly, a Christmas reply of thanks and blessing — not a theological answer. The discussion Charalampakis asked for never happened.

The Patriarchate's office had written once before. In May 1964 — a full year after his letter of 2 May 1963 — the Chief Secretary, Archimandrite Gabriel, wrote to say the letter had been lost. Charalampakis's answer is Letter 21, “The lost drachma”: the letter had gone by registered post — he kept the receipt, no. 18424 from the Central Post Office of Piraeus — and he had published it in his leaflet, which he sent to the Patriarch without fail. A lost letter, a year later, after registered delivery: he compares the Patriarchate to the woman in the parable who lost a coin and swept the house to find it. He sent a copy, gladly, together with two photocopies showing how the court of the Jerusalem Patriarchate had treated him — and a copy of his own letter of 18 January 1964 to Patriarch Benedict of Jerusalem — itself a reply to Jerusalem — which Benedict never answered.

Jerusalem's answer was of another kind. The court of the Jerusalem Patriarchate tore his leaflet in two, drew two mountzes — open palms, the Greek gesture of insult — on it, and mailed it back to him in an envelope. No reply letter came; Charalampakis prints the defaced leaflet under the caption «Ὅ,τι ἔχει ὁ καθένας προσφέρει» — “each offers what he has.” But the book also drew serious readers who took it seriously. William S. Thurman, head of the Classics department at the University of North Carolina at Asheville, who had met Charalampakis in Athens, wrote that his views “deserve a sympathetic hearing from all” — provided, he added, that “risky insulting expressions” are avoided and the arguments confirmed “with deep, persuasive and logical erudition.” An archimandrite and theologian, signing himself E.P., called the two books “Dynamite!” — “overwhelming and shattering, and as such an indispensable and necessary contribution to the restoration of the Orthodox Church” — and warned that much humility would be needed before the Orthodox could accept what they reveal. And Presbyter Aristarchos Veros, writing from Athens in January 1983, urged him to raise the banner of truth — but added the sentence that matters most: “The only method is gentleness, humility, love — not hatred or fanaticism.” His books, meanwhile, won three honorary awards from the Society of Greek Writers.

Why his story matters

Charalampakis is not an evangelical writer. He was an Orthodox priest, formed by Orthodoxy, who argued his case from Scripture, from the Fathers and from the history of the Church — and who paid for it with his own office. That is what makes him worth reading, and worth answering honestly rather than dismissing. A man who gives up his living for a conviction is not a man to be waved away.

The question he raised is the question this series takes up, one piece at a time: the priesthood of all believers; whether presbyters are priests; what “binding and loosing” meant; Christ's priesthood after the order of Melchizedek; and whether priests are the successors of the apostles. Each piece will take his arguments and evidence — and test them against Scripture, fairly stated and honestly weighed.

The tone is settled by his own friends. Thurman told him to avoid insulting expressions; Veros told him the only method is gentleness, humility and love; and Charalampakis himself hoped his book would create no religious passions. This site takes the same line: the arguments, in a measured voice — not the invective. The veil is torn, and the question is whether the Church lives as though it is. That is the conversation the Patriarch never had with him. It is still open.

Sources: Stylianos I. Charalampakis, ΤΟ ΒΑΣΙΛΕΙΟΝ ΙΕΡΑΤΕΥΜΑ (The Royal Priesthood), in 33 letters to the Ecumenical Patriarch — the introduction (twelve years as a cleric; the conclusion that there is no “special priesthood”; the defrocking, “freely and unforced”), Letter 1 (the priest's appeal to the Fathers), Letter 14 (the 1949 newspaper and the Patriarch's reported words; the defrocking on 14 February 1955; the letter of 22 May 1963 and the Patriarch's silence; the invitation to discuss it together), Letter 21 (“The lost drachma” — the Patriarchate's letter of 16 May 1964, through the Chief Secretary Archimandrite Gabriel, reporting his letter lost; his letter of 18 January 1964 to Patriarch Benedict of Jerusalem, unanswered); and ΤΑ ΑΝΑΠΟΔΑ ΤΗΣ ΘΡΗΣΚΕΙΑΣ (Athens, 1984, 2nd edition) — the prologue (the leaflet Spiritual Echoes growing into the book; the readers' letters) and the front matter of the book: Patriarch Athenagoras I's letter of Christmas 1964; the defaced leaflet returned by the court of the Jerusalem Patriarchate, printed under the caption «Ὅ,τι ἔχει ὁ καθένας προσφέρει»; William S. Thurman (University of North Carolina at Asheville); Archimandrite-Theologian E.P.; Presbyter Aristarchos Veros (Athens, 7 January 1983). Short quotations are used under fair use, with attribution; the rest is paraphrase and summary. Honest limits: the story is told from Charalampakis's own books, and the Patriarch's quoted words are as he reports them — from a 1949 newspaper clipping he kept in his archive, not independently verified here against the newspaper; Athenagoras's letter of Christmas 1964 is a reply of thanks and blessing, not an endorsement of Charalampakis's arguments, and the discussion he asked for never took place; the Jerusalem episode is presented as Charalampakis describes it (Letters 17 and 26), and no reply letter from Jerusalem appears in either book; his books are polemical in places, and this piece takes the arguments and evidence in a measured voice, not the invective. Scripture references are quoted from the English Standard Version.

Related reading: What Orthodoxy teaches about salvation — on salvation; What Orthodoxy teaches about the toll-houses — on the toll-houses, the soul's passage after death; Orthodox soteriology, from an Evangelical perspective — four talks by Rev. Giotis Kantartzis on salvation in Orthodox theology, with video, timestamped main points and English subtitles; In dialogue with Orthodoxy — the series this piece belongs to.

Researched and drafted with the help of Muse, an AI assistant. Every claim is checked against its sources, and every article is approved by Aris Angelakopoulos before publication.