EkklisiaAI for the ΑΩ

English · Διαβάστε στα ελληνικά →

Who is speaking — you or the algorithm?

20 November 2026 · 6 min read

Authorship and accountability in AI-assisted preaching.

A final-year philosophy student handed in a term paper made entirely of AI-generated material — and left the prompts attached. That is the story Fr Melchizedek Okpala told this week in a lecture on priestly formation in the age of artificial intelligence, and it is funny until you sit with it. The student had not just cheated. He had skipped the work the paper existed to do: the slow reflection, analysis and synthesis that turn reading into understanding. And he had done it so casually that he did not even remove the evidence.

The lecture — “Priestly Formation and Priestly Ministry in the Age of Artificial Intelligence” — was delivered to mark the 40th priestly anniversary of Most Rev. Dr. Anthony Ovayero Ewherido and Very Rev. Fr. Anthony Ogochukwu Anamali. Its question is the one in this article’s title, and it is the question Okpala puts at the heart of both seminary training and parish life: who is truly speaking — the priest, or the algorithm? His answer is a single line: “a priest must remain a conduit of living wisdom, not a conduit of generated content.”

Okpala is a Catholic priest speaking about priestly formation, and his lecture draws on Catholic teaching — St John Paul II’s Fides et Ratio and Pastores Dabo Vobis, the Dicastery for the Clergy’s Ratio Fundamentalis, and Pope Leo XIV’s Magnifica Humanitas. But the question travels. It is the same question this site’s sermon-writing article asked from the other side: where does AI help end and your calling begin? Okpala’s version is about authorship. The sermon article’s line was that preaching an AI-written sermon as your own is not, first, a disclosure problem — it is a content-integrity problem. Okpala shows why: the preacher is not presenting information. The preacher is standing behind words.

Standing behind words

That is the difference between a term paper and a sermon, and it is why the anecdote matters beyond the seminary. A paper is assessed on what it argues. A sermon is received on the authority of the person speaking it — their study, their prayer, their knowledge of the people in front of them. When a pastor says “this is what the text means, and this is what it asks of us,” the congregation is not evaluating a text. It is trusting a person who has wrestled with the text on their behalf.

That trust is exactly what uncritical AI use erodes. Okpala’s warning is that candidates who rely on generated content bypass the slow work needed for preaching, catechesis and moral guidance — and arrive in ministry unable to stand personally behind every word they speak. The same is true of a working pastor. A generated sermon may be accurate, well-structured, even moving. But if you did not wrestle with the passage, you cannot answer the question the sermon raises in the aisle afterwards. You cannot say why this application and not another, why this week and not last. The words are in your mouth, but they did not pass through you.

There is a second, quieter cost. Okpala describes AI advancing alongside a “philosophy of urgency” — a culture of speed and instant answers that crowds out contemplative silence, prayerful study and patient accompaniment. Sermon preparation has always been slow work, and the slowness is not inefficiency. It is the work. The pastor who outsources the slow part to save time has not saved time for ministry. He has given away the part of ministry that makes the rest of it possible.

The other direction: when the voice is not yours at all

Okpala also warns about the reverse problem. AI can now imitate the voices, images and videos of bishops, priests and other trusted figures, and bad actors can circulate fabricated church announcements, solicit fraudulent donations in the church’s name, damage reputations and erode public trust. His recommendation is that dioceses establish verified communication channels and teach clergy and the faithful to recognise manipulated content.

The same applies at parish level, and it is simpler than it sounds. A church needs one official channel for announcements and giving — its website, its bulletin, its verified account — and a congregation that knows to check it before acting on a message that looks like it came from the pastor. The deepfake of a priest asking for gift cards is not a hypothetical; it is already one of the commonest church scams. Authorship cuts both ways: your people need to know which words are yours, and which words merely sound like yours.

Three questions before Sunday

The sermon article ended with three checks — Scripture, illustrations, application. This is a different test, and it comes earlier: before the checks, ask whether the sermon is yours at all.

Did I write this? Not “did I approve it” — did the words pass through my own study and prayer? Research help is one thing; a generated outline, application and illustration that you lightly edited is another. If the honest answer is that the tool did the thinking, the sermon is not yours yet.

Could I preach it without the tool in the room? If the AI disappeared on Saturday night, could you still stand up on Sunday and say what you are going to say — and answer the questions it raises? If not, you do not own the material. You are renting it.

Would my congregation recognise this as mine? Not the voice alone — the people named, the week we are in, the thing only this church would understand. If the sermon could have been preached anywhere, to anyone, it has not passed through you yet.

If any of the three answers is no, the fix is not a better prompt. It is more time in the text.

Say it once, in writing

There is a practical step that makes the whole question easier, and it is the one the disclosure article already built. The site’s one-page AI disclosure template has a line for exactly this: “Sermons, lessons, and prayers are written by the person delivering them. AI does not write what is spoken, sung, or prayed in our services.” Put that line in your church’s disclosure, and the congregation does not have to guess. The trust Okpala is talking about stops depending on what people happen to assume, and starts resting on something the church has actually said.

That is also the answer to the worry the sermon article raised — the congregant who asks a chatbot to preach the same passage and says the machine did it better. The machine may well produce a smoother sermon. It cannot do what Okpala names at the end of his lecture: no algorithm can pray, receive grace, mature in friendship, or provide the embodied presence of a priest visiting the sick, grieving with families, reconciling estranged people, or celebrating the Eucharist. The sermon your congregation needs is not the most plausible thing that can be said about a passage. It is the version of that passage that passed through you. Say so, in writing, and then preach it.

Sources: Pelican Media Development, “Fr. Okpala Urges Priests to Guard Living Wisdom as Artificial Intelligence Reshapes Ministry in the Church”, 19 November 2026 — the lecture by Rev. Fr. Dr. Melchizedek Okpala, its title and occasion (the 40th priestly anniversary of Most Rev. Dr. Anthony Ovayero Ewherido and Very Rev. Fr. Anthony Ogochukwu Anamali), the “living wisdom, not generated content” thesis, the final-year philosophy student anecdote, the deepfake warning and the verified-channels recommendation. No full text of the lecture was found online and no second report of it turned up in search; this piece is built from the Pelican report, and the anecdote is Okpala’s own example as reported there, with no independent confirmation. The report gives no location for the lecture, so none is stated. Okpala is a Catholic priest speaking about priestly formation; the question is applied here to preaching generally.

Related reading: Writing a sermon with AI without losing your voice — the workflow this piece follows from, and the three checks before Sunday; A one-page AI disclosure your church can copy — the template with the authorship line; A church AI policy in a weekend — where the sermon-prep lines go; Churches are starting to govern AI, not just use it — the bishops’ AI task force and Pope Leo XIV’s Magnifica Humanitas; AI preps, people disciple — what AI can prep vs what stays human. This guidance is general and educational, not legal or safeguarding advice; your church’s own safeguarding, data-protection, and denominational policies always take precedence.